Flagside.football
Xavi Simons lors du match RC Lens / Paris Saint-Germain, rencontre en retard de la deuxième journée du championnat de France de Ligue 1 de football, le 10 septembre 2020 au Stade Bollaert-Delelis.

Xavi Simons & Mauro Icardi: PSG's odd couple of 2021-22

Photo: Supporterhéninois / Wikimedia Commons (CC0) · Source

Written with AI and checked automatically before publishing. How we work

One of these names means RB Leipzig's brightest attacking export and a Tottenham record fee. The other means Inter Milan's captain's armband and a decade of Serie A goals. Put Xavi Simons and Mauro Icardi side by side and the instinct is to assume they never crossed paths at all, yet for one season at Paris Saint-Germain, a teenage academy graduate and an established Argentine centre-forward were both drawing a PSG salary at the same time.

Two players, two completely different PSG stories

By 2021-22, Mauro Icardi was well established in Paris. He had arrived in 2019 on an initial loan from Inter Milan, the club where he'd been captain, twice topped the Capocannoniere charts, and been named Serie A Footballer of the Year in 2018. PSG made the move permanent for €50 million in 2020, and by the following season he was a regular contributor in attack, having already won a domestic treble and reached a Champions League final with the club.

Xavi Simons, meanwhile, was still trying to force his way into the picture. A La Masia product who had followed the well-worn path from Barcelona to Paris as a teenager, Simons made his senior PSG debut in February 2021 but spent much of the following season bouncing between the first team and Zoumana Camara's under-19 side. He didn't make his first Ligue 1 start for the club until February 2022, a 1-0 win over Rennes, having been sent back to train with the academy as late as August 2021.

A shared trophy, from very different vantage points

What connects them concretely is the 2021-22 Ligue 1 title, PSG's championship that season appearing on both men's honours lists. Icardi collected it as an established squad striker contributing to the campaign throughout. Simons collected it having featured only sporadically, a late substitute appearance here, a first senior assist for Kylian Mbappé in a cup tie there, but it counts all the same, and sits on his CV alongside the Coupe de France he'd already won in 2021.

Where the two careers diverged completely

The contrast only sharpens either side of that season. Icardi had arrived at PSG via Sampdoria and a trophy-laden spell at Inter, where he remains one of the club's highest-ever goalscorers. After Paris, he moved to Galatasaray, first on loan, then permanently, where he became a serial Süper Lig champion and the division's top scorer in 2023-24.

Simons went the opposite direction entirely. He left PSG for PSV Eindhoven in 2022, won the Eredivisie top scorer award in his only season there, then returned to Paris only to be loaned straight back out, this time to RB Leipzig, where he became the identity most readers now associate with him, before a £51.8 million move to Tottenham Hotspur in 2025.

Why the pairing still works

Neither man is remembered as a Paris Saint-Germain player first and foremost. Icardi's name belongs to Inter and, increasingly, Galatasaray; Simons's belongs to Leipzig and now Spurs. But for one Ligue 1 campaign, an Argentine international striker approaching his peak and a Dutch teenager still waiting for his senior breakthrough were squad-mates under the same badge, a pairing that only makes sense once you remember just how many players have passed through the same Parisian dressing room on wildly different trajectories.

Sources2 sources

We name and link every outlet this article draws on, and rewrite their reporting in our own words rather than reprinting it.

Share this story

One of these names means RB Leipzig's brightest attacking export and a Tottenham record fee. The other means Inter Milan's captain's armband and a decade of Serie A goals.

YOUR CALL

Will Simons prove the better long-term signing than Icardi turned out to be?

Comments

Loading comments…

MORNING BRIEF

The day's football, in your inbox at 7 AM. Nothing else.

Pick of the night's matches, what the transfer window's doing, and the one column you should read today. No ads. No tips. No operators.

One-click unsubscribe. We do not share emails.