Tuchel has no regrets. England fans do.

The game England had, and gave away

Gordon's goal handed England exactly the platform they needed: a lead, a crowd behind them, and an Argentina side that had to come out. What followed, according to widespread reports from the match, was a tactical retreat so pronounced it drew immediate condemnation from journalists and pundits at the ground. Tuchel shifted to a defensive shape and made substitutions designed to protect the lead rather than extend it. Argentina, given the space and the invitation, turned the game around.

The exact scoreline and the nature of Argentina's goals — open play or set-piece — have not been confirmed, which matters when you're trying to apportion blame precisely. What is confirmed is the result: England are out at the semi-final stage, and the manager's fingerprints are all over the second half.

'No regrets'

Post-match, Tuchel was asked about the approach. His answer, per CaughtOffside, was unambiguous: no regrets. He defended the decision to sit deep after Gordon's goal, framing it as a calculated risk rather than a failure of nerve. The press conference did not go well for him.

The problem with 'no regrets' as a public position is that it requires the result to back you up. When it doesn't, it reads less like conviction and more like a man who hasn't quite processed what happened yet. Tuchel is a manager who has won a Champions League — he knows what bold looks like. England's second half, by most accounts, was not it.

What comes next

England have now reached a World Cup semi-final and lost it in a manner that has united pundits against the manager's approach — which, given how rarely pundits agree on anything, tells you something about how bad the second half looked. The Football Association will have to decide whether Tuchel's contract continues, and that conversation will happen in the shadow of a very specific question: if you have Argentina on the back foot and your response is to defend, what exactly is the plan?

Tuchel will have his answers. Whether the FA — and England fans — are still listening is the only question that matters now.